who are the good mods?

topic posted Wed, June 24, 2009 - 5:05 PM by  Unsubscribed
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
with the recent threads being rather negative with respect to mods I thought perhaps there may be something to gain from exploring who and why we regards certain mods as good.....

in my own experience I found blue-j ( people.tribe.net/blue-j ) the moderator for the evolution and evolutionary psycology tribes to moderate well when threads became or threatened to become abusive and similarly a good poster and comentator in his own right.

perhaps if we explored the qualities that make a good moderator we could all gain something useful.....

any other nominations???

regards

gm23
posted by:
Unsubscribed
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: who are the good mods?

    Wed, June 24, 2009 - 6:13 PM
    gypsy star of Developing Psychic Abilities

    Rev of Raw Wisdom

    Linda of Herbal Wisdom


    • Unsu...
       

      Re: who are the good mods?

      Wed, June 24, 2009 - 6:16 PM
      good,

      but what in your opinion makes them good mods?
      • Re: who are the good mods?

        Wed, June 24, 2009 - 6:56 PM
        very fair
        go to their tribes ancd contribute knowledge as well as discussion topics

        never namecall or denigrate another
        allow differences of opinion

        help to discuss when 2 people apparently have different understandings of somethign when a conflict occuyrs

        will PM with readers to discuss

        do not delete things with no reason and very rarely delete things

        if they do delete it is by request or from a major troll or explosion
        • Re: who are the good mods?

          Thu, June 25, 2009 - 11:12 PM
          I agree about Rev Ro being a good mod. She's likely the best among the public tribes I visit. You can tell she's present everyday and has the qualities you list, cathyq. She keeps on coming up with interesting things to discuss and she responds to the threads others start, too.

          Aunt Bea is also a great mod. She also is present in her tribe. She commands great loyalty there. She has a great sense of humor.

          She is also very fair with people, tolerating all kinds (probably more than I would) and rarely deletes things. She gives warning before removing a post or, on rare occasion, a person. Her tribe Ask, Aunt Bea has been trolled a lot in recent months, and she hasn't shut down the troll(s), but somehow managed to keep (most) people happy in her tribe even with a strong troll presence.

          She starts welcome threads on each and every avatar that joins her tribe in a uniquely interesting way. Her tribe is always very active.
          • Re: who are the good mods?

            Mon, June 29, 2009 - 10:01 AM
            I rescind my words re Linda.. She can get lecturey out of the blue and put downey!

            I left the tribe after 2 lectures .. of course that thread is erased!
            • Re: who are the good mods?

              Mon, June 29, 2009 - 6:16 PM
              Good mods:

              Bobzilla

              Elaine

              BryTee

              Those are with Burningman-associated tribes which are notoriously difficult to moderate.
              • Re: who are the good mods?

                Mon, June 29, 2009 - 6:17 PM
                Oh yes, add greenman 23. I happen to like his style. Very informative. And he knows huge amounts about the subject (Agricultural Soil Science)
                • Unsu...
                   

                  Re: who are the good mods?

                  Tue, June 30, 2009 - 9:48 AM
                  thanks Rhino for the vote of support...

                  but as I started this thread and ASS is a very small and specialist tribe...

                  I'm a bit of a minnow

                  that said the point of the thread was to illicit what made a good mod... so far it looks like what most of us would suspect... balanced, informed and detached...

                  good mods know their subject or at least know the extent of their knowledge in it and realise that others are not as knowledgeable ... whereas other make you look a fool in comparison... being able to laugh at both is therefore essential.

                  regards

                  gm23

Recent topics in "Tribe Moderators"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Getting new members during a recession JM 13 October 19, 2009
what is ... "other mail" ? yogamoon 2 September 19, 2009
What if you MOD a dead tribe? What to do? yogamoon 21 September 14, 2009
what is the point of this tribe? Unsubscribed 11 September 4, 2009